Registry (pyvo.registry)

This is an interface to the Virtual Observatory Registry, a collection of metadata records of the VO’s “resources” (“resource” is jargon for: a collection of datasets, usually with a service in front of it). For a wider background, see 2014A&C…..7..101D for the general architecture and 2015A&C….10…88D for the search interfaces.

There are two fundamental modes of searching in the VO:

  1. Data discovery: This is when you are looking for some sort of data collection based on its metadata; a classical example would be something like “I need redshifts of supernovae”.

  2. Service discovery: This is what you need when you want to query all services of a certain kind (e.g., „all spectral services claiming to have infrared data“), which in turn is the basis of all-VO dataset discovery (“give me all infrared spectra of 3C273”)

Both modes are supported by this module.

Basic interface

The main interface for the module is pyvo.registry.search(); the examples below assume:

>>> from pyvo import registry

This function accepts one or more search constraints, which can be either specified using constraint objects as positional arguments or as keyword arguments. The following constraints are available:

  • Freetext (keywords): one or more freetext words, mached in the title, description or subject of the resource.

  • Servicetype (servicetype): constrain to one of tap, ssa, sia1, sia2, conesearch (or full ivoids for other service types). This is the constraint you want to use for service discovery.

  • UCD (ucd): constrain by one or more UCD patterns; resources match when they serve columns having a matching UCD (e.g., phot.mag;em.ir.% for “any infrared magnitude”).

  • Waveband (waveband): one or more terms from the vocabulary at http://www.ivoa.net/rdf/messenger giving the rough spectral location of the resource.

  • Author (author): an author (“creator”). This is a single SQL pattern, and given the sloppy practices in the VO for how to write author names, you should probably generously use wildcards.

  • Datamodel (datamodel): one of obscore, epntap, or regtap: only return TAP services having tables of this kind.

  • Ivoid (ivoid): exactly match a single IVOA identifier (that is, in effect, the primary key in the VO).

  • Spatial (spatial): match resources covering, enclosed or overlapping a certain geometry (point, circle, polygon, or MOC). RegTAP 1.2 Extension

  • Spectral (spectral): match resources covering a certain part of the spectrum (usually, but not limited to, the electromagnetic spectrum). RegTAP 1.2 Extension

  • Temporal (temporal): match resources covering a some point or interval in time. RegTAP 1.2 Extension

Multiple constraints are combined conjunctively (”AND”).

Constraints marked with RegTAP 1.2 Extension are not available on all IVOA RegTAP services (they are on pyVO’s default RegTAP endpoint, though). Also refer to the class documentation for further caveats on these.

Hence, to look for for resources with UV data mentioning white dwarfs you could either run:

>>> resources = registry.search(keywords="white dwarf", waveband="UV")

or:

>>> resources = registry.search(registry.Freetext("white dwarf"),
...                             registry.Waveband("UV"))

or a mixture between the two. Constructing using explicit constraints is generally preferable with more complex queries. Where the constraints accept multiple arguments, you can pass in sequences to the keyword arguments; for instance:

>>> resources = registry.search(registry.Waveband("Radio", "Millimeter"),
...   registry.Author("%Miller%"))

is equivalent to:

>>> resources = registry.search(waveband=["Radio", "Millimeter"],
...   author='%Miller%')

There is also get_RegTAP_query(), accepting the same arguments as pyvo.registry.search(). This function simply returns the ADQL query that search would execute. This is may be useful to construct custom RegTAP queries, which could then be executed on TAP services implementing the regtap data model.

Data Discovery

In data discovery, you look for resources matching your constraints and then figure out in a second step how to query them. For instance, to look for resources giving redshifts in connection with supernovae, you would say:

>>> resources = registry.search(registry.UCD("src.redshift"),
...                             registry.Freetext("AGB"))

After that, resources is an instance of RegistryResults, which you can iterate over. In interactive data discovery, however, it is usually preferable to use the to_table method for an overview of the resources available:

>>> resources.to_table()  
<Table length=9>
              ivoid               ...
                                  ...
              object              ...
--------------------------------- ...
     ivo://cds.vizier/j/a+a/392/1 ...
   ivo://cds.vizier/j/a+a/566/a95 ...
    ivo://cds.vizier/j/aj/151/146 ...
    ivo://cds.vizier/j/apj/727/14 ...
...

And to look for tap resources in a specific cone, you would do

>>> from astropy.coordinates import SkyCoord
>>> registry.search(registry.Freetext("Wolf-Rayet"),
...                 registry.Spatial((SkyCoord("23d +3d"), 3), intersect="enclosed"))
<DALResultsTable length=2>
             ivoid              ...
                                ...
             object             ...
------------------------------- ...
ivo://cds.vizier/j/a+a/688/a104 ...
  ivo://cds.vizier/j/apj/938/73 ...

Astropy Quantities are also supported for the radius angle of a SkyCoord-defined circular region:

>>> from astropy import units as u
>>> registry.search(registry.Freetext("Wolf-Rayet"),
...                 registry.Spatial((SkyCoord("23d +3d"), 180*u.Unit('arcmin')), intersect="enclosed"))
<DALResultsTable length=2>
             ivoid              ...
                                ...
             object             ...
------------------------------- ...
ivo://cds.vizier/j/a+a/688/a104 ...
  ivo://cds.vizier/j/apj/938/73 ...
Where intersect can take the following values:
  • ‘covers’ is the default and returns resources that cover the geometry provided,

  • ‘enclosed’ is for services in the given region,

  • ‘overlaps’ returns services intersecting with the region.

The idea is that in notebook-like interfaces you can pick resources by title, description, and perhaps the access mode (“interface”) offered. In the list of interfaces, you will sometimes spot an #aux after a standard id; this is a minor VO technicality that you can in practice ignore. For instance, you can simply construct TAPService-s from tap#aux interfaces.

Once you have found a resource you would like to query, you can pick it by index; however, this will not be stable across multiple executions. Hence, RegistryResults also supports referencing results by short name, which is the style we recommend. Using full ivoids is possible, too, and safer because these are guaranteed to be unique (which short names are not), but it is rather clunky, and in the real VO short name collisions should be very rare.

Use the get_service method of RegistryResource to obtain a DAL service object for a particular sort of interface. To query the fourth match using simple cone search, you would thus say:

>>> voresource = resources["J/ApJ/727/14"]
>>> voresource.get_service(service_type="conesearch").search(pos=(257.41, 64.345), sr=0.01)
<DALResultsTable length=1>
   _r    recno f_ID         ID          RAJ2000  ... SED  DR7  Sloan Simbad
                                          deg    ...
float64  int32 str1       str18         float64  ... str3 str3  str5  str6
-------- ----- ---- ------------------ --------- ... ---- ---- ----- ------
0.000618     1    P 170938.52+642044.1 257.41049 ...  SED  DR7 Sloan Simbad

This method will raise an error if there is more than one service of the desired type. If you know for sure that all declared conesearch will be the same, you can safely use get_service(service_type='conesearch', lax=True) that will return the first conesearch it finds.

However some providers provide multiple services of the same type – for example in VizieR you’ll find one conesearch per table. In this case, you can inspect the available Interface to services with list_interfaces. Then, you can refine your instructions to get_service with a keyword constraint on the description get_service(service_type='conesearch', keyword='sncat').

>>> for interface in voresource.list_interfaces():
...     print(interface)
Interface(type='tap#aux', description='', url='http://tapvizier.cds.unistra.fr/TAPVizieR/tap')
Interface(type='vr:webbrowser', description='', url='http://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-2?-source=J/ApJ/727/14')
Interface(type='conesearch', description='Cone search capability for table J/ApJ/727/14/table2 (AKARI IRC 3-24{mu}m, and Spitzer MIPS 24/70{mu}m photometry of Abell 2255 member galaxies)', url='http://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/conesearch/J/ApJ/727/14/table2?')

Or construct the service object directly from the list of interfaces with:

>>> voresource.list_interfaces()[0].to_service()
TAPService(baseurl : 'http://tapvizier.cds.unistra.fr/TAPVizieR/tap', description : '')

The list of interfaces can also be filtered to interfaces corresponding to services of a specific service type:

>>> voresource.list_interfaces("tap")
[Interface(type='tap#aux', description='', url='http://tapvizier.cds.unistra.fr/TAPVizieR/tap')]

To operate TAP services, you need to know what tables make up a resource; you could construct a TAP service and access its tables attribute, but you can take a shortcut and call a RegistryResource’s get_tables method for a rather similar result:

>>> tables = resources["J/ApJ/727/14"].get_tables()  
>>> list(tables.keys())
['J/ApJ/727/14/table2']
>>> sorted(c.name for c in tables["J/ApJ/727/14/table2"].columns)
['[24]', '[70]', 'dej2000', 'dr7', 'e_[24]', 'e_[70]', 'e_l15', 'e_l24', 'e_n3', 'e_n4', 'e_s11', 'e_s7', 'f_id', 'gmag', 'id', 'imag', 'l15', 'l24', 'n3', 'n4', 'raj2000', 'recno', 'rmag', 's11', 's7', 'sed', 'simbad', 'sloan', 'umag', 'y03', 'z', 'zmag']

In this case, this is a table with one of VizieR’s somewhat funky names. To run a TAP query based on this metadata, do something like:

>>> resources["J/ApJ/727/14"].get_service(service_type="tap#aux").run_sync(
...   'SELECT id, z FROM "J/ApJ/727/14/table2" WHERE z>0.09 and umag<18')
<DALResultsTable length=1>
        ID            z
      object       float64
------------------ -------
171319.90+635428.0 0.09043

A special sort of access mode is web, which represents some facility related to the resource that works in a web browser. You can ask for a “service” for it, too; you will then receive an object that has a search method, and when you call it, a browser window should open with the query facility (this uses python’s webbrowser module):

>>> resources["J/ApJ/727/14"].get_service(service_type="web").search()  

Note that for interactive data discovery in the VO Registry, you may also want to have a look at Aladin’s discovery tree, TOPCAT’s VO menu, or at services like DataScope or WIRR in your web browser.

Service Discovery

Service discovery is what you want typically in connection with a search for datasets, as in “Give me all infrared spectra of Bellatrix“. To do that, you want to run the same DAL query against all the services of a given sort. This means that you will have to include a servicetype constraint such that all resources in your registry results can be queried in the same way.

When that is the case, you can use each RegistryResource’s service attribute, which contains a DAL service instance. The opening example could be written like this:

>>> from astropy.coordinates import SkyCoord
>>> my_obj = SkyCoord.from_name("Bellatrix")
>>> for res in registry.search(waveband="infrared", servicetype="ssap"):
...     print(res.service.search(pos=my_obj, size=0.001))
...

In reality, you will have to add some error handling to this kind of all-VO queries: in a wide and distributed network, some service is always down. See Appendix: Robust All-VO Queries.

The central point is: With a servicetype constraint, each result has a well-defined service attribute that contains some subclass of dal.Service and that can be queried in a uniform fashion.

TAP services may provide tables in well-defined data models, like EPN-TAP or obscore. These can be queried in similar loops, although in some cases you will have to adapt the queries to the resources found.

In the obscore case, an all-VO query would look like this:

>>> for svc_rec in registry.search(datamodel="obscore"):
...     print(svc_rec.service.run_sync(
...           "SELECT DISTINCT dataproduct_type FROM ivoa.obscore"))

Again, in production this needs explicit handling of failing services. For an example of how this might look like, see GAVO’s plate tutorial

More examples

Discover archives

You can use the registry search method (or the regsearch function) to discover archives that may have x-ray images and then query those archives to find what x-ray images that have of CasA. For the arguments you will enter 'image' for the service type and 'x-ray' for the waveband. The position is provided by the Astropy library.

The query returns a RegistryResults object which is a container holding a table of matching services. In this example it returns 33 matching services.

>>> import pyvo as vo
>>> from astropy.coordinates import SkyCoord
>>>
>>> import warnings
>>> warnings.filterwarnings('ignore', module="astropy.io.votable.*")
>>>
>>> archives = vo.regsearch(servicetype='sia1', waveband='x-ray')
>>> pos = SkyCoord.from_name('Cas A')
>>> len(archives)   
33

There are also other type of services that you can choose via the servicetype parameter, for more details see Servicetype.

You can learn more about the archives by printing their titles and access URL:

>>> for service in archives:
...     print(service.res_title, service.access_url)  
Chandra X-ray Observatory Data Archive https://cda.harvard.edu/cxcsiap/queryImages?
Chandra Source Catalog Release 1 http://cda.cfa.harvard.edu/csc1siap/queryImages?
...

It is not necessary to keep track of the URL because you can search images directly from the registry record, for example using the Chandra X-ray Observatory (CDA) service and the search method, inserting the position and size for the desired object.

>>> images = archives["CDA"].search(pos=pos, size=0.25)
>>> len(images)   
822

Sometimes you are looking for a type of object. For this purpose, the keywords parameter is useful here. For example, you want to find all catalogs related to blazars observed with Fermi:

>>> cats = vo.regsearch(keywords=['blazar', 'Fermi'])
>>> len(cats)   
551

Or you already know the particular catalog but not the base URL for that service. For example, you want to get cutout images from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS):

>>> colls = vo.regsearch(keywords=['NVSS'], servicetype='sia1')
>>> for coll in colls:
...     print(coll.res_title, coll.access_url)
NRA) VLA Sky Survey https://skyview.gsfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/vo/sia.pl?survey=nvss&
Sydney University Molonglo Sky Survey https://skyview.gsfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/vo/sia.pl?survey=sumss&

Search results

What is coming back from registry.search is pyvo.registry.RegistryResults which is rather similar to Resultsets and Records; just remember that for interactive use there is the to_tables method discussed above.

The individual items are instances of RegistryResource, which expose many pieces of metadata (e.g., title, description, creators, etc) in attributes named like their RegTAP counterparts (see the class documentation). Some attributes deserve a second look.

>>> import pyvo as vo
>>> colls = vo.regsearch(keywords=["NVSS"], servicetype='sia1')
>>> nvss = colls["NVSS"]
>>> nvss.res_title
'NRA) VLA Sky Survey'

If you are looking for a particular data collection or catalog, as we did above when we looked for the NVSS archive, often simply reviewing the titles is sufficient. Other times, particularly when you are not sure what you are looking for, it helps to look deeper.

A selection of the resource metadata, including the title, shortname and description, can be printed out in a summary form with the describe function.

>>> nvss.describe(verbose=True)
NRA) VLA Sky Survey
Short Name: NVSS
IVOA Identifier: ivo://nasa.heasarc/skyview/nvss
Access modes: sia
- sia: https://skyview.gsfc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/vo/sia.pl?survey=nvss&
...

The verbose option in describe will output more information about the content of the resource, if available. Possible added entries are the authors of the resource, an associated DOI, an url where more information is provided, or a reference to a related paper.

The method service will, for resources that only have a single capability, return a DAL service object ready for querying using the respective protocol. You should only use that attribute when the original registry query constrained the service type, because otherwise there is no telling what kind of service you will get back.

>>> nvss = colls["NVSS"].service  # converts record to service object
>>> nvss.search(pos=(350.85, 58.815),size=0.25,format="image/fits")
<DALResultsTable length=1>
Survey    Ra   ... LogicalName
object float64 ...    object
------ ------- ... -----------
  nvss  350.85 ...           1

With this service object, we can either call its search function directly or create query objects to get cutouts for a whole list of sources.

>>> cutouts1 = nvss.search(pos=(148.8888, 69.065), size=0.2)
>>> nvssq = nvss.create_query(size=0.2)  # or create a query object
>>> nvssq.pos = (350.85, 58.815)
>>> cutouts2 = nvssq.execute()

Our discussion of service metadata offers an opportunity to highlight another important property, the service’s IVOA Identifier (sometimes referred to as its ivoid). This is a globally-unique identifier that takes the form of a URI:

>>> colls = vo.regsearch(keywords=["NVSS"], servicetype='sia1')
>>> for coll in colls:
...     print(coll.ivoid)
ivo://nasa.heasarc/skyview/nvss
ivo://nasa.heasarc/skyview/sumss

This identifier can be used to retrieve a specific service from the registry.

>>> nvss = vo.registry.search(ivoid='ivo://nasa.heasarc/skyview/nvss')[0].get_service(service_type='sia1')
>>> nvss.search(pos=(350.85, 58.815),size=0.25,format="image/fits")
<DALResultsTable length=1>
Survey    Ra   ... LogicalName
object float64 ...    object
------ ------- ... -----------
  nvss  350.85 ...           1

When the registry query did not constrain the service type, you can use the access_modes method to see what capabilities are available. For instance with this identifier:

>>> res = registry.search(ivoid="ivo://org.gavo.dc/flashheros/q/ssa")[0]
>>> res.access_modes()  
{'ssa', 'datalink#links-1.0', 'tap#aux', 'web', 'soda#sync-1.0'}

– this service can be accessed through SSA, TAP, a web interface, and two special capabilities that pyVO cannot produce services for (mainly because standalone service objects do not make much sense for them).

To obtain a service for one of the access modes pyVO does support, use get_service(service_type=mode). For web, this returns an object that opens a web browser window when its query method is called.

RegistryResources also have a get_contact method. Use this if the service is down or seems to have bugs; you should in general get at least an e-Mail address:

>>> res.get_contact()
'GAVO Data Centre Team (+49 6221 54 1837) <gavo@ari.uni-heidelberg.de>'

Finally, the registry has an idea of what kind of tables are published through a resource, much like the VOSI tables endpoint (as a matter of fact, the Registry should contain exactly what is there, as VOSI tables in effect just gives a part of the registry record). Not all publishers properly provide table metadata to the Registry, though, but most do these days, and then you can run:

>>> res.get_tables()  
{'flashheros.data': <VODataServiceTable name="flashheros.data">... 29 columns ...</VODataServiceTable>, 'ivoa.obscore': <VODataServiceTable name="ivoa.obscore">... 0 columns ...</VODataServiceTable>}

Alternative Registries

There are several RegTAP services in the VO. PyVO by default uses the one at the TAP access URL http://reg.g-vo.org/tap. You can use alternative ones, for instance, because they are nearer to you or because the default endpoint is down.

You can pre-select the URL by setting the IVOA_REGISTRY environment variable to the TAP access URL of the service you would like to use. In a bash-like shell, you would say:

export IVOA_REGISTRY="http://vao.stsci.edu/RegTAP/TapService.aspx"

before starting python (or the notebook processor).

Within a Python session, you can use the pyvo.registry.choose_RegTAP_service function, which also takes the TAP access URL.

As long as you have on working registry endpoint, you can find the other RegTAP services using:

>>> res = registry.search(datamodel="regtap")
>>> print("\n".join(sorted(r.get_interface(service_type="tap", lax=True).access_url
...   for r in res)))
http://dc.zah.uni-heidelberg.de/tap
http://gavo.aip.de/tap
http://voparis-rr.obspm.fr/tap
https://vao.stsci.edu/RegTAP/TapService.aspx

Reference/API

pyvo.registry Package

a package for interacting with registries.

The regtap module supports access to the IVOA Registries

Functions

search(*constraints[, includeaux, maxrec])

execute a simple query to the RegTAP registry.

get_RegTAP_query(*constraints[, includeaux, ...])

returns SQL for a RegTAP query for constraints and keywords.

choose_RegTAP_service(access_url)

changes the RegTAP service used by search() to the one at access_url.

Classes

Constraint()

an abstract base class for data discovery contraints.

SubqueriedConstraint()

An (abstract) constraint for when the constraint is over a table other than rr.resource.

Freetext(*words)

A constraint using plain text to match against title, description, subjects, and person names.

Author(name)

A constraint for creators (“authors”) of a resource; you can use SQL patterns here.

Servicetype(*stds)

A constraint for for the availability of a certain kind of service on the result.

Waveband(*bands)

A constraint on messenger particles.

Datamodel(dmname)

A constraint on the adherence to a data model.

Ivoid(ivoid, *more_ivoids)

A constraint selecting a single resource by its IVOA identifier.

UCD(*patterns)

A constraint selecting resources having tables with columns having UCDs matching a SQL pattern (% as wildcard).

Spatial(geom_spec, *[, order, intersect, ...])

A RegTAP constraint selecting resources covering a geometry in space.

Spectral(spec, *[, inclusive])

A RegTAP constraint on the spectral coverage of resources.

Temporal(times, *[, inclusive])

A RegTAP constraint on the temporal coverage of resources.

RegTAPFeatureMissing([reason, label, url])

Raised when the current RegTAP server does not support a feature needed for a constraint.

RegistryResults(votable, *[, url, session])

an iterable set of results from a registry query.

RegistryResource(results, index, *[, session])

a dictionary for the resource metadata returned in one record of a registry query.

Class Inheritance Diagram

Inheritance diagram of pyvo.registry.rtcons.Constraint, pyvo.registry.rtcons.SubqueriedConstraint, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Freetext, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Author, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Servicetype, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Waveband, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Datamodel, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Ivoid, pyvo.registry.rtcons.UCD, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Spatial, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Spectral, pyvo.registry.rtcons.Temporal, pyvo.registry.rtcons.RegTAPFeatureMissing, pyvo.registry.regtap.RegistryResults, pyvo.registry.regtap.RegistryResource

pyvo.registry.regtap Module

a module for basic VO Registry interactions.

A VO registry is a database of VO resources–data collections and services–that are available for VO applications. Typically, it is aware of the resources from all over the world. A registry can find relevant data collections and services through search queries–typically, subject-based. The registry responds with a list of records describing matching resources. With a record in hand, the application can use the information in the record to access the resource directly. Most often, the resource is a data service that can be queried for individual datasets of interest.

This module provides basic, low-level access to the RegTAP Registries using standardized TAP-based services.

Functions

search(*constraints[, includeaux, maxrec])

execute a simple query to the RegTAP registry.

get_RegTAP_query(*constraints[, includeaux, ...])

returns SQL for a RegTAP query for constraints and keywords.

ivoid2service(ivoid[, servicetype])

Deprecated since version 1.5.

Classes

Interface(access_url, *[, standard_id, ...])

a service interface.

RegistryResource(results, index, *[, session])

a dictionary for the resource metadata returned in one record of a registry query.

RegistryResults(votable, *[, url, session])

an iterable set of results from a registry query.

Class Inheritance Diagram

Inheritance diagram of pyvo.registry.regtap.Interface, pyvo.registry.regtap.RegistryResource, pyvo.registry.regtap.RegistryResults

pyvo.registry.rtcons Module

Constraints for doing registry searches.

The Constraint class encapsulates a query fragment in a RegTAP query, e.g., a keyword, a sky location, an author name, a class of services. They are used either directly as arguments to registry.search, or by passing keyword arguments into registry.search. The mapping from keyword arguments to constraint classes happens through the _keyword attribute in Constraint-derived classes.

Functions

build_regtap_query(constraints, service)

returns a RegTAP query ready for submission from a list of Constraint instances.

Appendix: Robust All-VO Queries

The VO contains many services, and even if all of them had 99.9% uptime (which not all do), at any time you would always see failures, some of them involving long timeouts. Hence, if you run all-VO queries, you should catch errors and, at least in interactive sessions, provide some way to interrupt overly long queries. Here is an example for how to query all obscore services; remove the break at the end of the loop to actually do the global query (it’s there so that you don’t blindly run all-VO queries without reading at least this sentence):

>>> from astropy.table import vstack
>>> from pyvo import registry
>>>
>>> QUERY = "SELECT TOP 1 s_ra, s_dec from ivoa.obscore"
>>>
>>> results = []
>>> for i, svc_rec in enumerate(registry.search(datamodel="obscore", servicetype="tap")):
...       # print("Querying {}".format(svc_rec.res_title))
...       try:
...           svc = svc_rec.get_service(service_type="tap", lax=True)
...           results.append(
...               svc.run_sync(QUERY).to_table())
...       except KeyboardInterrupt:
...           # someone lost their patience with a service.  Query next.
...           pass
...       except Exception as msg:
...           # some service is broken; you *should* complain, but
...           #print("  Broken: {} ({}).  Complain to {}.\n".format(
...           pass #    svc_rec.ivoid, msg, svc_rec.get_contact()))
...       if i == 2:
...           break
>>> total_result = vstack(results)  
>>> total_result  
<Table length=5>
       s_ra               s_dec
       deg                 deg
     float64             float64
------------------ -------------------
          350.4619            -9.76139
  208.360833592735    52.3611106494996
  148.204840298431    29.1690999975089
        243.044008          -51.778222
321.63278049999997 -54.579285999999996

Note that even this is not enough to reliably cover use cases like „give me all images of M1 in the X-Ray in the VO“. In some future version, pyVO will come with higher-level functionality for such tasks.